Iggy Pop at the Meltdown Festival with a tasting of Côtes du Rhône Wines
A punk gig at the all-seater Royal Festival Hall is somewhat incongruous at the best of times - punk was never meant to be corporate.
In the UK, at least, punk was a short-lived late 70s phenomenon of pent-up angst and frustration, with a do-it-yourself approach whose energy quickly receded but not before it had enthused and infused a wave of new styles - post-punk, ska, Celtic rock, even early New Romantics - until corporate pop took over for much of the 80s.
Warm-up act Savages had angst, energy and intensity aplenty - but lacked much in the way of identifiable melodies. Getting themselves told by the stage manager that their droning finale of "Don't Let the [obscenity] Get You Down" had gone on too long and it was now time to wind up was an ignominious ending that they, and their few ardent fans, affected not to notice.
The main event of the evening, Iggy Pop - the Godfather of Punk - was, of course, superb, a great live act with noise, energy and presence - but also some tunes.
Appearing in his trademark, stripped-to-the-waist guise, skin-tight jeans and boots, he was, as Matt Walls observed, a blond-haired skeleton covered in slices of ham.
Unlike Lux Interior of The Cramps who always seemed unhinged enough to revel in his own campy, punkish ridiculousness or Mick Jagger who has the air of an energetic ring master, Iggy just seems to accept his fate as a performing punk for hire in his 60s.
Surely, at his age he could do something more dignified to make a living - maybe advertising car insurance ?
So substance and a sense of occasion, then - even if it was all too slick and assured to have any real sense of danger or edginess. And last year's event - the Twickenham double header - had that same mix of adrenaline, noise and sheer sense of occasion.
Côtes du Rhône, it seems, know how to put on a good show; and this is perhaps appropriate, for, as my World Atlas of Wine says, Rhône wines have "substance" - the same substance, intensity and sense of occasion as a rugby match or a punk gig.
Here are the wines I though best.
CdR Villages Laudun, Reserve du Boulas 2012 (£7.99, M&S) good entry level Rhone white
Condrieu, Jaboulet Aine, Domaine des Grands Amandiers, 2011 (£45.49, Bibendum) ripe, smokey, peachy, full and concentrated. Very Good, but not cheap.
CdR, Ortas Cave de Rasteau, Les Viguiers, 2011 (£7.95, Hercules) very pleasant rose with ripe red fruits.
CdR, Les Vignerons d'Estezargues, Domaine de Pierredon, 2012 (£9.95, Roberson) tasting note tbc. Good
CdR Villages Cairanne, Boutinot, La Cote Sauvage, 2009 (£12.99, independents) smokey spice, ripe fruit, good texture and concentration, soft ripe tannins. Very Good.
Rasteau, Domaine Les Grands Bois, Cuvee Marc 2011 (£15 Gauntley of Nottingham) lots of texture and grip, quite oaky now and needs time to show its potential. Good.
Rasteau, Domaine des Escaravailles, La Ponce 2010 (£13, Cambridge Wine Merchants) sweet vanilla, pencil shavings , ripe fruit, almost over-cooked but just about held together. Good.
Saint-Joseph, Cave de Tain, Esprit de Granit, 2010 (£18, independents) spice, muskiness, pencil shavings and well-hung game; intense and concentrated. Very Good Indeed.
Other related articles
Rhone Double Header
Three Jean-Luc Colombo reds
Rhone wines at Justerini and Brooks
Rhone En Primeur at Cambridge Wine Merchants
Côtes du Rhône - website
Olivier LeGrand, Inter Rhône- twitter